top of page

Convincing the Investment Committee: Making a Hard Sell for Acquisition or Disposition


In the world of commercial real estate, acquiring exclusive listings often necessitates a persuasive pitch to the investment committee (IC). However, convincing the IC to approve acquisitions or dispositions—especially in challenging market conditions—can be a hard sell. So, how do you effectively argue your case and gain the committee's approval? Here's a guide to making a compelling pitch, persuading the IC, and sealing that exclusive commercial listing.


Understand Your Audience

First and foremost, understanding the IC is crucial. Each member brings a unique perspective, and they all collectively seek to mitigate risks and maximize returns. Therefore, make sure you are well-versed with their priorities, investment criteria, and concerns.


Do Your Homework

Before you make your pitch, gather all relevant information about the property in question. This includes:

  • Market data: Provide comprehensive information on current market trends, comparable sales, and the impact of economic indicators on the property value.

  • Financial analysis: Prepare a detailed financial model demonstrating the potential returns and profitability of the acquisition or disposition. Use conservative estimates to avoid overselling.

  • Risk assessment: Identify potential risks and propose strategies to mitigate them. Show the IC that you've considered worst-case scenarios and have a plan in place.


Tailor Your Approach

To get the IC's approval, you must align your proposal with the committee's goals and investment strategy. Are they looking for short-term profitability or long-term value appreciation? Do they prefer core, core-plus, value-add, or opportunistic investments? Once you understand the IC's investment strategy, tailor your pitch accordingly.


Tell a Story

Data is crucial, but to truly capture the IC's attention, weave your numbers into a narrative. Talk about the property's unique selling points, its potential for value creation, and how it fits into the larger market scenario. Use visuals and concise language to keep your presentation engaging. Visuals are crucial!


Address the Elephant in the Room

If there are obvious drawbacks or risks associated with the property, address them head-on. Show the IC that you've thought through these challenges and have a strategy in place to manage them. This will demonstrate your thoroughness and boost the committee's confidence in your proposal.


Handle Objections Gracefully

Prepare for possible objections and questions. If a committee member raises a concern, respond gracefully. Avoid becoming defensive; instead, use this as an opportunity to provide further insights or clarify any misunderstanding.


Reiterate the Opportunity

At the end of your pitch, reiterate the unique opportunity that this acquisition or disposition presents. Whether it's a promising location, a below-market price, or a high-demand property type, reminding the IC of the potential benefits can leave a lasting impression.


Follow Up

After your presentation, be proactive in addressing any additional queries that the IC might have. Send a follow-up note thanking the IC for their time and providing any additional information they requested.


In conclusion, persuading an IC to approve an acquisition or disposition is an art that combines thorough research, strategic storytelling, and graceful handling of objections. By understanding the IC's priorities and presenting a compelling, data-backed narrative, you can make a hard sell seem less daunting, securing that exclusive commercial listing and contributing to the success of your firm.

bottom of page